Congressional agencies used in the oversight process

It could stop delegating its significant rulemaking power, thus preserving its authority over the rules that govern the American people. The removal of the legislative veto left Congress in a bind. 4 This method whereby delegations by Congress of rulemaking authority to the executive were accompanied by mechanisms allowing for one or both houses of Congress to reverse particular exercises of such authority was held to violate the ConstitutionвЂ™s clauses regarding bicameralism and presentment. In 1983, a key device for congressional oversight, the so-called legislative veto, was struck down by the Supreme Court in the landmark separation of powers ruling INS v. 3ДЄs regulations have played an increasingly important role in the lives of Americans, conventions for overseeing them and checking excesses have fallen by the wayside. 2 In addition to the problem of democratic legitimacy, the separation of regulatory authority from democratic responsibility can lead to bad rulemaking. 1 This development is problematic in a country that claims democratic governance, as regulators are unelected and unaccountable to the people except insofar as their representatives are able and willing to exercise effective oversight. Agency-crafted regulations have increasingly pushed aside congressionally authored statutes in scope and importance, much as statutes once pushed aside the common law. The lack of Congressional oversight of the regulatory process is a problem of long standing. To join the debate, please email us at Introduction We also invite responses from our readers. Whenever we publish an article that advocates for a particular position, as here, we offer links to other perspectives on the issue, including ones opposed to the position taken in the article you can find those links at the right side of this page. Any expressions of opinion are those of the author.

The Federalist Society takes no positions on particular legal and public policy matters.

This article critiques current procedures for agency rulemaking and proposes an alternative.

Congressional agencies used in the oversight process